Pi hole vs pfsense

Your browser does not seem to support JavaScript. As a result, your viewing experience will be diminished, and you may not be able to execute some actions. Please download a browser that supports JavaScript, or enable it if it's disabled i. A lot of people want content filtering.

pi hole vs pfsense

DNS content filtering is the best bet for almost everyone. If you run a Pi-Hole DNS filter for blocking adds and malicious site already, you can add porn quite easily. Add this url to the lists. Do you actively use pi-hole from a raspberry pi for clients or do you run it as a VM on whatever hypervisor they have available?

I don't have a problem with some types of filtering - catch all the major porn, etc sites - but it should be mainly the easy to catch stuff, i. Beyond that - yeah it should be an HR issue. I spun up a VM with Fedora 27 minimal, and then installed with a 1-liner, and a wizard.

Entire process probably took 10 minutes. Great product. Why is this not working for me?

Pi-hole as All-Around DNS Solution

Pihole is working but when I add this list then search pornhub it still comes up. Interesting concept. Register Login. Add porn blocking to your Pi-hole This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.

pi hole vs pfsense

Reply Quote 11 1 Reply Last reply. Reply Quote 0 1 Reply Last reply. Awesome, thanks! It would definitely stop of lot of main websites.

Intuitively I just want to start using it. Reply Quote 2 1 Reply Last reply. Yeah HR should be doing their job rather than having IT police the internet for em. Just did this. Pi-Hole is amazing so far. Reply Quote 1 1 Reply Last reply. It's a great, and decently simple, product.Main repository for pfSense. The biggest advantage is ad blocking on all devices on the network from your smartphone to your tablets including all desktop computers.

Sophos This was a live podcast discussing these two products. PHP Apache License 2. Its not a review or an in depth look. Any chance I have to keep network requests sanitary I will take for How to install and configure Pi-hole by Milosz Galazka on January 11, and tagged with RaspberryEnhanced security Install Pi-hole a network-wide ad blocking on your own Linux hardware.

A modular IRC bot for Python 13 Mar For those of us - myself included - who run a hosts file list either using dnsmasq like Pi-hole or directlyhere are the sources that Pi-hole use D:.

There are many reoccurring costs involved with maintaining free, open source, and privacy-respecting software; expenses which our volunteer developers pitch in to cover out-of-pocket. Instead, you just use your pfSense pfBlockerNG! Any new device added to the network should automatically have ads blocked. How hard is it to configure and what steps do I need to take? Im running the latest version of pfsense, on a Netgear APU4. In addition to blocking advertisements, Pi-hole has an informative Web interface that shows stats on all the domains being queried on your network.

Do not enable DNS Forwarder. This should happen automatically, with no manual configuration of DNS settings on each device. The one that made the most sense to -pfSense itself does not need ad blocking internally, so it should not rely on the pi. Do not enable DNS Resolver. Thats also why Pi-hole is popular, its really easy to set up and also running DNS on a separate box is always a plus.

Please read the rules before posting, thanks! Press J to jump to the feed. The Pi-Hole was a quick and easy project, and it does exactly what it was intended to do. That said, I imagine that pfsense can do the very same thing. However, pfBlockerNG is far more powerful.

To use it together with a PfSense firewall you need to change a few firewall settings: -pfSense itself does not need ad blocking internally, so it should not rely on the pi. After applying the blocking lists, it forwards requests made by the clients to configured upstream DNS server s. I then changed DNS from pi-hole to my pfsense server and then opened the same page in a new tab. You can install it on a Debian based Linux distributions.I have been using pfSense as my home router for a few years.

A few months ago, I decided to setup PiHole on a Raspberry Pi to block ads across all devices on my network. This post outlines how I accomplished this. This should happen automatically, with no manual configuration of DNS settings on each device. Any new device added to the network should automatically have ads blocked. In my case, OpenDNS. The reason for this is that I like having the ability to create DNS entries and aliases for machines within my network if needed.

Managing this in pfSense is easy. In order for Pi-Hole to function properly, it needs to have a consistent IP address. Scroll down to the bottom, then click on Add to create a new Static Mapping. Because my pfSense router is I downloaded the latest version of Raspbian and cloned it onto an SD card.

I then connected the Pi to a monitor, keyboard, mouse, and ethernet, and booted it up. I logged in and started the Pi-Hole installer. I recommend doing the semi-automated install rather than piping to bash.

The wizard is fairly straight forward. The one important step is the the upstream DNS setting. You could have this forward directly to a public DNS server. See the Pi-Hole documentation for information about this page. I did not need to make any changes to configuration here. A much better way is to have pfSense hand out Scroll down a little bit to the server section and you will see a DNS Servers field. Note: Depending on your DHCP lease time, it may take some time for all of the devices on the network to get the new address.

You can manually renew the DHCP lease or reboot devices to speed this process up if you would like.

pi hole vs pfsense

There were a few cases where Pi-Hole would block an ad, which would then cause the entire video to not load. NOTE: You could also create a static mapping the same way we did for the Pi, but since the device is already on the network, pfSense will already have the MAC address filled out for us.

In this section, make sure the MAC address is already filled out. Scroll down and click on Save. Zach Tarr Nerd.I started with a number of lists from the Pi-hole ad block list. If you do this trust me, I did at firstthen you will only block your access to the actual block list feeds in question. To fix this you will need to remove the block, clear the feeds, clear the caches, and possibly restart your router.

To test my feeds, I tried to visit advertising site directly, and the router blocked my DNS request! Per their package description, "ntopng replaces ntop is a network probe that shows network usage in a way similar to what top does for processes. I enabled the plugin, told my settings to persist, changed the default admin password, and configured it for my LAN.

Additionally, the interface chart was cool to see how much bandwidth my network was using, and when. Hey Doyler, great post. Will have to check this out. Your PFSense is deployed at home? Do I need to enable and configure unbound as a forwarder or resolver of some sort?

Not stupid, and glad to help. Have you done that yet? Hey Doyler, great write up! Should I leave that blank for my ads to be blocked or can I still use 8. Thanks, and glad to help! Heads up, pfblocker now supports domain blacklists for web filtering purposes, including support for Squidblacklist. We are a subscription based service, gotta pay the bills, but we do have some free stuff for the community as well, so come on over and check it out.

Hi There. Just got my first pfSense device today — a HP thinclient pre-loaded with pfSense 2. Super excited.

Able to reach it just fine. What am I missing? Awesome, great to hear! Hmm, there are a few possibilities. First, are you sure that that site is on one of the feeds you selected? If not, try to select a different URL that you know is on the list.

Hi doyler great guide, i was wondering if you know how to white list a site when using DNSBL I am able to white list stuff when just using pfblockerng but not when using the lists with DNSBL any help with this would be great. Any chance you know how to block YouTube ads?

I have tried a few things with pi-hole in the past but could never get anything working. Sorry for doing your head in, but I have tried a few things now to get the amazon shopping app for android to work any chance you have any idea what to whitelist to get it working?

Also I found a list that blocks YouTube ads. I forget exactly what you need to unblock since I normally just use the web version. That said, the easiest thing to do in this case is to go to the logs and view the dnsbl.

This will show you what was blocked most recently, and you can start white-listing via that!

Atomic Pi pfSense Router / Firewall

Okay I just wanted to throw this out there. Here is a collection of lists that are well vetted and up to date. I cannot get pfBlockerNG to work.Instead, you just use your pfSense pfBlockerNG! I love pfSense and if I could only install one package to enhance its capabilities, it would undoubtedly be pfBlockerNG. Advertising is great because it pays content creators for their work. After all, even this site utilizes Google Ads, albeit very very lightly. So why would I create a write-up on blocking ads?

The install should only take a minute or so depending on your internet connection and firewall. This option is required for the TLD blacklists discussed later in the walkthrough. What does the TLD feature provide?

The feeds below are large, but they are very good feeds.

Install and Configure pfBlockerNg for DNS Black Listing in pfSense Firewall

If you using a system with limited resources mainly RAMthen these might not be for you. When in doubt, add the feeds slowly and keep an eye on memory, CPU, etc. Sites silently autofilling and extracting email addresses and other information for tracking. These lists in conjunction with two above are what is used by default with the pi-hole project if you are trying to mimic it. These are additional feeds that are simply a little easier to add. I found these to be mostly unusable because they broke several things mainly related to Amazonbut your mileage may vary.

Now, go over to the Update tab within pfBlockerNG. Heed the warning in the first red box and make sure you are not going to run the updates near the time your cron job would automatically run. If the countdown timer is less than 3 minutes, I would not recommend running it and instead just wait for the system to run it automatically. You will see progress updates in the gray window below including the number of domains downloaded by each list. So what does the finished product look like? A browser add-on like uBlock Origin discussed below further cleans this up by removing the gray box entirely and it also provides some secondary protections.

If you visit Yahoo. Normally, you would ping br. However, with pfBlockerNG properly setup you will instead see a reply of Feel free to test this against any domain in any one of the lists that you added. If you followed all of my examples above for both ads and malicious sites, you will likely have a DNSBL list that is well into the hundreds of thousands if not millions. Afterall, it is bound to happen.

You can either remove the offending list entirely or more preferably, you can just whitelist the domain.In an earlier article the installation of a powerful FreeBSD based firewall solution known as pfSense was discussed. This article is going to talk about a wonderful add-on package for pfsense called pfBlockerNG. As the capabilities of attackers and cyber criminals continues to advance, so must the defenses that are put in place to thwart their efforts.

The ability to restrict on items such as domain names is very advantageous as it allows administrators to thwart attempts of internal machines attempting to connect out to known bad domains in other words, domains that may be known to have malware, illegal content, or other insidious pieces of data. This article will make a couple of assumptions and will build off of the prior installation article about pfSense. The assumptions will be as follows:. The image below is the lab diagram for the pfSense environment that will be used in this article.

With the lab ready to go, it is time to begin! The first step is to connect to the web interface for the pfSense firewall. Again this lab environment is using the Some browsers may complain about the SSL certificate, this is normal since the certificate is self signed by the pfSense firewall.

You can safely accept the warning message and if desired, a valid certificate signed by a legitimate CA can be installed but is beyond the scope of this article.

The pfSense login page will then display and allow for the administrator to log in to the firewall appliance. Clicking this link will change to the package manager window. The first page to load will be all the currently installed packages and will be blank again this guide is assuming a clean pfSense install. The first item that is returned should be pfBlockerNG. Once confirmed, pfSense will begin to install pfBlockerNG. Do not navigate away from the installer page!

Wait until the page displays successful installation. Once the installation has been completed, the pfBlockerNG configuration can begin.

Linux Included

The first task that needs to be completed though is some explanations on what is going to happen once pfBlockerNG is configured properly. When the page reloads, the DNS resolver general settings will be configurable. The next settings are to set the DNS listening port normally port 53setting the network interfaces that the DNS resolver should listen on in this configuration, it should be the LAN port and Localhostand then setting the egress port should be WAN in this configuration.

The next step is the first step in configuration of pfBlockerNG specifically. This IP needs to be in the private network range and not a valid IP on the network in which pfSense is being used. For example, a LAN network on This IP will be used to gather statistics as well as monitor domains that are being rejected by pfBlockerNG. Scrolling down the page, there are a few more settings worth mentioning.In this guide, I will walkthrough how to install and test the pi-hole on Ubuntu and more specifically, Ubuntu Server.

These same instructions may work on Ubuntu Desktop, but I strongly suggest Server. Why Ubuntu instead of a Raspberry Pi? I love Raspberry Pis and I probably own at least 10 of them. Instead, the project officially supports So why install it on Ubuntu I install systems with the intention to not make significant changes to them for some time and the end of life for Changelog 24July — Originally posted 1Sept — Added steps to fix Additional steps for Added section on removing hosts-file.

Advertising is great because it pays content creators for their work. After all, even this site utilizes Google Ads. So why would I create a write-up on blocking ads? As a result, blocking advertising has become an absolute necessity for those who are security conscious. As many have figured out, a side benefit of blocking ads is a better user experience and a substantial drop in bandwidth usage. If you own a pfSense, I would strongly suggest using the aforementioned guide to create an experience very similar to the pi-hole.

Using pfBlockerNG on pfSense has quite a few additional features such as IP blocking and quite honestly, there is no need to add yet another system to manage. Installing Ubuntu server is ridiculously easy. Note: There is a slight difference in the install steps if you are installing I explain where the 2 install paths diverge in the Ubuntu You can safely use the defaults throughout the installation, although I would install security updates automatically when given the option.

You may also need to install SSH if that is how you plan to access and manage your server remotely other than the web interface.

You could potentially require more resources if you have a lot of devices or those devices make a ton of DNS requests. That is something you will need to keep an eye on after you get it up and running! After your Ubuntu system finishes the install and reboots, login via an SSH terminal or from the console.

You should be greeted with a welcome screen similar to the one below with the exception your package and security update counts may be different.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *